Skip to main content

Popular Stigma Files

Email a Friend Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Daily Telegraph journalist Annette Sharp has been at the centre of a social media flurry after her article 13 reasons Jesinta and Buddy should postpone their summer wedding offered advice to AFL player Lance 'Buddy' Franklin who has recently taken time off due to mental health issues and his fiance, Jesinta Campbell.

In her piece, Sharp wrote that,'Because Jesinta may still be absorbing the news that mental illness can be hereditary,' and 'Because Jesinta’s appeal and allure will halve when she marries as half the consumer market — men — rapidly lose interest in their dream girl when she is no longer single,' were reasons for the two to postpone their marriage.

Sharp also commented on Franklin's mental health treatment.

The Telegraph recieved much criticism for the piece on it's Facebook page, summarised here by mUmBRELLA.

Fellow commentators and journalists quickly responded with their own pieces, for example Neil McMahon on ABC's The Drum.

As did Jesinta Campbell herself with this Facebook post:

jesinta campbell tweet 468x468

StigmaWatchers joined the outcry, one contributor wrote, 'This seemed to imply that she [Jesinta] should be seriously reconsidering whether to marry or have children with her partner now that he has a mental illness. I found this incredibly stigmatizing. I am happily married with two children and a serious mental illness. I was disappointed that this publication would suggest someone should not marry or have children with a partner because they have a mental illness.'

The Huffington Post reports that the couple are alledgedly seeking legal advice in regard to the piece and the Australian Press Council has also recieved complaints.

Sharp's piece is a timely reminder that journalists and commentators should stick to what they know and get the facts before reporting on mental illness.

Journalists can contact the This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. for advice on mental illness reporting, as did one reporter, who was working on a piece on football and mental illness, vox popping players at the Brownlow Medal red carpet, following Sharp's article.